Why Emotional Intelligence is the Most Overrated Leadership Skill (And Why You Still Need It)

Related Articles:

• Managing Difficult Conversations
• Stress Management Training

Every second business consultant in Melbourne seems to bang on about emotional intelligence these days. Walk into any corporate training session and you'll hear about EQ this, EQ that, as if it's some magical cure for every workplace problem from poor sales to coffee machine arguments.

Here's the thing though - after 18 years running leadership programs across Brisbane, Sydney, and Perth, I've seen enough "emotionally intelligent" leaders crash and burn to know it's not the silver bullet everyone claims it is.

But before you roll your eyes and click away, hear me out.

The Problem with the EQ Obsession

The emotional intelligence movement has created a generation of leaders who think feelings trump facts. I've watched perfectly good managers second-guess every decision because they're too busy worrying about whether they're being "emotionally aware" enough.

Take Sarah, a client of mine who runs a logistics company in Adelaide. Brilliant strategist, knows her numbers inside out, but she spent six months avoiding a necessary restructure because her EQ training told her to "consider everyone's emotional needs first." Meanwhile, the company hemorrhaged $200,000 and three key clients jumped ship.

That's not emotional intelligence. That's emotional paralysis.

The real issue is that most EQ training focuses on the touchy-feely stuff while ignoring the hard skills that actually make leaders effective. Reading the room is valuable, sure, but it means nothing if you can't make tough decisions or communicate clearly when the pressure's on.

What Actually Works (And What Doesn't)

Here's where I'll probably upset some people: most emotional intelligence training is backwards. Instead of teaching leaders to manage their emotions, we should be teaching them to use their emotions strategically.

The best leaders I've worked with - from mining executives in Western Australia to tech startup founders in Sydney - don't suppress their emotions or constantly analyse them. They channel them.

Anger can drive innovation when it's directed at inefficiencies. Frustration can fuel problem-solving. Fear can sharpen risk assessment. But you won't learn this from your typical corporate EQ workshop that focuses on breathing exercises and empathy mapping.

Real emotional intelligence in leadership comes down to three things:

Situational awareness. Knowing when to be the tough boss and when to be the supportive mentor. This isn't about reading facial expressions - it's about understanding business context and timing.

Authentic communication. People can smell fake empathy from a mile away. Better to be genuinely direct than artificially understanding. I've seen more trust built through honest, difficult conversations than through months of "emotionally intelligent" dancing around issues.

Emotional leverage. Using your emotional state to influence outcomes. When I'm passionate about a project, that energy is contagious. When I'm concerned about risks, that caution can prevent disasters.

The Data Doesn't Lie (Even When EQ Trainers Do)

Research from the Australian Institute of Management shows that 73% of successful leaders rate technical competence as more important than emotional intelligence for business outcomes. Yet 89% of leadership development budgets still go toward soft skills training.

We're solving the wrong problem.

The most effective leaders I know combine high emotional awareness with ruthless commercial focus. They understand feelings - both their own and others' - but they don't let emotions drive strategy. They make data-driven decisions and then use emotional intelligence to implement those decisions effectively.

Where EQ Actually Matters

Don't get me wrong - emotional intelligence has its place. But it's more tactical than strategic.

It's useful for reading stakeholder reactions during presentations. For knowing when your team is burnt out before productivity crashes. For sensing when a client is ready to buy or when they're about to walk away.

But it's not useful for setting direction, making tough resource decisions, or driving performance improvements. Those require analytical thinking, commercial awareness, and sometimes the courage to be unpopular.

I learned this the hard way early in my career when I was running a training consultancy in Brisbane. I spent so much time trying to keep everyone happy and emotionally supported that I nearly ran the business into the ground. The wake-up call came when my accountant - brilliant woman, zero patience for emotional waffle - told me straight: "Your empathy is admirable, but it's not paying the bills."

She was right. Sometimes leadership means making decisions that upset people, cutting budgets that affect livelihoods, and having conversations that no amount of emotional intelligence can make comfortable.

The Real Secret? Emotional Discipline

What successful leaders actually need isn't more emotional intelligence - it's emotional discipline. The ability to feel emotions without being controlled by them. To acknowledge concerns without being paralysed by them. To show empathy without compromising standards.

This is different from the emotional suppression that older generations of leaders practised. It's not about becoming robotic. It's about becoming intentional with your emotional responses.

When a project goes wrong, feel the frustration. Use it to fuel your analysis of what went wrong. But don't let it cloud your judgment about next steps. When an employee is struggling, feel genuine concern. Let it motivate you to provide support. But don't let it prevent you from maintaining performance expectations.

Making EQ Work in the Real World

If you're going to invest in emotional intelligence development - and there are good reasons to do so - make sure it's practical. Skip the theoretical frameworks and focus on specific scenarios you'll actually face.

Practice having difficult conversations with real stakes. Learn to read the commercial implications of emotional dynamics. Understand how your emotional state affects your decision-making under pressure.

And for the love of all that's holy, don't let emotional intelligence training become an excuse for avoiding hard leadership decisions. The most emotionally intelligent thing a leader can do sometimes is disappoint people in service of larger goals.

Your team doesn't need you to be their therapist. They need you to be their leader. That means making tough calls, setting clear expectations, and sometimes prioritising business outcomes over individual comfort levels.

The companies thriving in today's market combine high emotional awareness with uncompromising commercial focus. They understand people AND they understand profit. They care about culture AND they care about results.

That's the kind of emotional intelligence worth developing. Everything else is just expensive therapy disguised as leadership training.

---

Looking to develop practical emotional intelligence skills for your leadership team? Our approach focuses on commercial outcomes, not corporate fluff. Get in touch to learn more about training that actually works.